Ajemian v. Yahoo!, Inc.
Last week, the Appeals Court issued a much-anticipated decision in Ajemian v. Yahoo!, Inc., No. 12-P-178 (May 7, 2013), which concerns the question of whether the decedent’s e-mails in his Yahoo! account are property of his estate.
The Appeals Court reversed and remanded, holding that res judicata did not bar the present suit in Massachusetts, and that neither the forum selection clause nor the one-year limitations period stated in the TOS barred the present suit in Massachusetts. The Appeals Court explained that the TOS, which was in the form of a “browsewrap” agreement (where terms and conditions are posted as a hyperlink on the website), had not been reasonably communicated to the decedent or accepted by him. The Appeals Court also explained that it would be unreasonable to enforce the TOS against the administrators, who were not parties to the agreement, and that Massachusetts is the proper jurisdiction to hear the dispute because the decedent was domiciled in Massachusetts and the administrators are residents of Massachusetts.
The Appeals Court declined to address the question of whether the decedent’s e-mails in his Yahoo! account are property of his estate, and thus whether the administrators can access those e-mails. “In these circumstances, the question is best addressed on remand after full briefing and such further proceedings as the probate judge deems appropriate.” So, for the answer to this question, it would seem that we must stay tuned.
The Boston Bar Association Trusts & Estates Section Blog provides information as a service to its users and BBA members. Neither the Trusts & Estates Section nor the Boston Bar Association are a law firm and do not represent clients in any way. Although the information on this site is about legal issues and informational services it is not legal advice. Use of this blog does not in any way create a lawyer-client relationship. If you need a lawyer, the Boston Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service can refer you to a qualified attorney. http://www.bostonbarlawyer.org/ or call 617-742-0625.